Percy Jackson vs Hercules (Disney) - Battles - Comic Vine (2024)

Movie Percy gets stomped.

Book Percy outclasses Hercules in every way.

Why does Percy have the power of the gods? Book version of him takes Hercules with standard powers.

Percy is a demigod so he already has some godlike power. That said, movie Herc slaughters him because of vastly superior feats. Didn't read the book so idk about that.

Round 1-Hercules

Round 2-I don't know

Hercules, picked up a tornado. That's power.

Book Percy wins.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H7GtE0BZXJA

@Agent9149: Dude, Percy picked up the sky. Do you know how many tornandos there can be in the sky?

@cooljammy18: Percy's feats are far above Hercules'.

@logy5000: Hercules held the sky for prolong period as a favor for atlas

@Agent9149: No he didn't, this is disney version.

@logy5000: http://youtu.be/FbU6LQKD_YM

disney herc has most of real herc's feats

@logy5000: Hercules rerouted the river Styx, and threw the titans into space

@Agent9149: Percy BATHED in the Styx, and defeated many titans himself. (PJO titans were above Disney titans.)

@logy5000 said:

@darkelf35: Percy was stated to be above Hercules from mythology.

@Agent9149: Percy can do the same......

So are you going to ignore the fact that you definitively stated that movie Hercules didn't do that, before Agent posted conclusive proof of the contrary?

Not really impressed with your argument thus far.

@logy5000: bathing in the Styx is not a better feat than rerouting it;

What are the feats of the titans in the book?

@Skyfather: I had forgotten about that part.

I don't take newcomers' opinions to heart. No offense.

@logy5000 said:

@darkelf35: Percy was stated to be above Hercules from mythology.

@Agent9149: Percy can do the same......

If we are going from mythology i think Perseus and hercules are 1/2 brothers both are children of zeus. They but Hercules was stated to be the strongest demigod of all time. (strongest man that ever lived)

@logy5000: You already inserted your foot in your mouth this thread once based on assumption. I really don't see how it's in your best interests to repeat that mistake after so short a respite, but then again, I can't be sure you're acting in your best interests when you jump from conclusion to conclusion to begin with.

I can tell I'm not going to be impressed with any of your other arguments any time soon, either. You first declare a statement erroneously in this thread, fail to apologize or own up to the error, instead opting to change the topic and seek another method of attack. Next, you attempt to discredit my criticism of said tactic by implying that a newcomer's opinion has no merit to you. Well, what merit do the rest of us here give to someone so arrogant as to make a comment like that? The fact is that I wasn't wrong, and you were. Let's leave it at that, and keep the ad hominem attacks for someone naive enough to buy into them, all the while ceasing to insult the intelligence of all of ComicVine while we're at it.

Round 1: Hercules

Round 2: Stalemate

@darkelf35: At the end of the last olympian Poseidon told Percy: "You have surpassed all demigods...... not even Hercules," but he was interrupted.

@Skyfather: I'm impressed that you're trying to sound highly intelligent by saying: "I'm right, you're wrong." You say that I'm insulting you, (which wasn't my intention,) and what was it that you did immediately after?

I'm not saying your opinion has no value, but I'm more ready to take criticism from somebody with more experience on the vine. Trust me, I was treated the same way.

"all the while ceasing to insult the intelligence of all of ComicVine while we're at it." You shouldn't say things like that when you haven't been around long enough to know me.

PJ titans are far above disney titans. Titans in their true form can destroy a human who is in their presence, while disney titans got their ass kicked by a mortal named Hercules.

bro, Percy literally went to Tartarus and back —— that's power. If he really is desperate, he can most likely just drain all the water from Hercules's body. (He probably won't but... he can)

Herc throws him out of the solar system.